On subreddits, Discord servers, and TikTok, conspiracy theories about Luigi Mangione have taken on a life of their own. With tens of thousands of followers, these online communities are dedicated to uncovering the truth behind the man who allegedly shot the CEO of United Healthcare and the number 286. From dissecting his distinctive eyebrows to analyzing every aspect of the shooting and his arrest, these theories have exploded in the week since Mangione’s arrest. While some fans have embraced him as a left-wing folk hero, others are determined to prove his innocence through a Monopoly-linked trail of clues. Amidst the chaos of these competing theories, one thing is clear: the online world of conspiracy theories dedicated to Mangione is a fascinating and ever-evolving landscape.